Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

Read this scenario and answer the following questions. Tim and a friend had been drinking at a bar. When they left around 1:15 AM, they encountered two men

April 28, 2024

Read this scenario and answer the following questions.

Tim and a friend had been drinking at a bar. When they left around 1:15 AM, they encountered two men Tim recognized as regular customers at the liquor store where he worked. He invited the men to come back to his house with his friend to smoke marijuana. Once there, one of the men held a gun to Tim’s head and demanded Tim give him his money, which he did; the two men immediately left.

A neighbor called police a few minutes later to report a burglary, describing the men as African American and one wearing a large hooded flannel shirt. Tim, meanwhile, left with his friend to search for the men and ended up stopping a police officer who happened to be responding to the burglary call. Another officer also responding to the call saw two men walking near Tim’s residence; he couldn’t tell their race, but one had a large hooded flannel shirt. When the officer turned his car to face the men, they ran between two house.

Using a canine unit, they located Tyrone, an African American male who was not wearing a flannel shirt. Tyrone told police he’d had an argument with his girlfriend and ran when he saw the patrol car because he feared she had called the police. Arrested and searched, no weapons or money were found on him. Tyrone was placed in a patrol car and driven to Tim’s residence to give Tim the opportunity to identify him as one of the suspects (this is what is called a “showup”). The overhead light in the car was left on. “Some guy was found running around nearby,” the officer who went to Tim’s home told Tim. “Will you come take a look at him?” Tim agreed and, when asked if Tyrone was one of the men, Tim said, “I’m 97% certain.” He indicated this was due to Tyrone’s size and hairstyle.

Both Tim and Tyrone were taken to the police station. Tim then observed Tyrone, seated alone in a room, through a two-way mirror. Again, Tim identified Tyrone as the man who robbed him. Not long after, Tim was shown Tyrone’s mug shot and Tim identified him for a third time.

Tyrone was convicted of armed robbery and appealed his conviction, claiming the first showup was unnecessarily suggestive because he sat alone in the patrol car, Tim was intoxicated, and the police had made certain comments to Tim about Tyrone.Show ups, in which only a single suspect is shown to a witness, have been ruled to be a lawful police practice, even if they are suggestive of guilt due to the isolation of the suspect. This is why Tyrone claims the actions were “unnecessarily” suggestive, going beyond the inevitable but acceptable suggestiveness the courts have acknowledged.

1. No matter what the courts have said, do YOU think showing a single suspect to someone is acceptable practice and, if so, under what conditions?

2. Do you agree with police showing a suspect to the witness while in a patrol car or while wearing handcuffs, as Tyrone was? Why or why not is this acceptable?

3. Do you think the comment made by police to Tim about Tyrone was appropriate? Why or why not?

Share This Post

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Qualitative methods research paper Parenting Styles and Child Development related to crime • Analyze different parenting approaches and their perceived

Qualitative methods research paper Parenting Styles and Child Development related to crime • Analyze different parenting approaches and their perceived impact on child behavior and development. How it can be involved with why people commit crimes when they are older -topic and workable approach -workable approach -literature review list (10

Answer all five questions, each questions should have a response of approximately 300-400 words 1. Identify and discuss two of the methods that have been

Answer all five questions, each questions should have a response of approximately 300-400 words 1. Identify and discuss two of the methods that have been used to regulate prescription drug use and lower risks associated with their use. 2. Identify and discuss two different ways in which the federal government

HEADING: The Necessity and scope of animal cruelty laws Animal cruelty laws no doubt remain some of the most vital ways to guarantee animal welfare and

HEADING: The Necessity and scope of animal cruelty laws Animal cruelty laws no doubt remain some of the most vital ways to guarantee animal welfare and penalize parties responsible in cases of inhumane treatment. It is moderately effective since such a law is handling abuses, but its enforcement is still

All 50 states have enacted animal cruelty laws. Read Georgia’s law, O.C.G.A. § 16-12-4. Then, read the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to

All 50 states have enacted animal cruelty laws. Read Georgia’s law, O.C.G.A. § 16-12-4. Then, read the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)’s Position Statement on Protection of Animal Cruelty Victims. Formulate a 500-word written response to the following questions based on the information presented on the

Physical Evidence Analysis Assignment You are tasked with developing profiles of three people from the contents of their trash cans. Each person’s trash

Physical Evidence Analysis Assignment You are tasked with developing profiles of three people from the contents of their trash cans. Each person’s trash can contains seven items which are listed below. All you know about the trash is that it was picked up from different neighborhoods around metro-Atlanta. Be as

Each part must be a minimum of 250 words. W1: The United States court system is like a series of huge, overlapping webs. Your reading gives you some

Each part must be a minimum of 250 words. W1: The United States court system is like a series of huge, overlapping webs. Your reading gives you some information about the different levels and kinds of court. Sometimes figuring this out can be messy. To help you with that, this

Week 2 Citation Assignment This week we are going to practice Bluebook citations and look at the quality of sources. Below are several random sources.

Week 2 Citation Assignment This week we are going to practice Bluebook citations and look at the quality of sources. Below are several random sources. They are also in the attached Word document. Please write the correct Bluebook citation for each source and identify whether the source is peer-reviewed or

Choose one transnational crime group (historic or current) and describe its (in no particular

Choose one transnational crime group (historic or current) and describe its (in no particular order): History/Objectives Location/Geopolitics Economy/Funding Organization/Logistics Effect on the host state Cooperation with terror groups (if applicable) Include a conclusion listing the problems your group causes/caused. Be sure to cite sources/facts/statistics/information, and use headings to separate the

Exposition Instructions Objective: Imagine you are at an interview, networking session, conference, or another similar professional event. You want to

Exposition Instructions Objective: Imagine you are at an interview, networking session, conference, or another similar professional event. You want to share a meaningful message with an audience about a complex concept we discussed in this course that you found especially important or interesting; however, your audience may be unfamiliar with the

Please answer both of the following Discussion Questions: Class,As identified by research regarding both traditional and online education, higher forms of

Please answer both of the following Discussion Questions: Class,As identified by research regarding both traditional and online education, higher forms of learning take place when students are able to take an active part in curriculum development.Subsequently, this week the questions are a bit different from those weeks before and after.Rather

1. Please discuss the Threat Assessment (2011) promulgated by the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and the role that Organized Crime Groups

1. Please discuss the Threat Assessment (2011) promulgated by the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and the role that Organized Crime Groups and Narco-Traffickers are perpetuating narcotics abuse and addiction. 2. In conducting additional research outside of this week’s readings, select a specific area, town, city, or

What makes cybercrime so difficult to detect, investigate and prosecute? Provide examples. No AI, no plagiarism.

In 1971, the Supreme Court concluded in Reed v. Reed, 404 U.S. 71 (1971) that an Idaho law that discriminated against women was unconstitutional under the

In 1971, the Supreme Court concluded in Reed v. Reed, 404 U.S. 71 (1971) that an Idaho law that discriminated against women was unconstitutional under the Fourteenth Amendment. Before this case, no court had ever made such a ruling. Two other key Fourteenth Amendment cases from the 1970s concerned jury duty for women: Taylor v.

For this Discussion, let’s take a page out of the public health model and swim upstream. Swimming upstream means identifying and treating the root cause of

For this Discussion, let’s take a page out of the public health model and swim upstream. Swimming upstream means identifying and treating the root cause of a problem rather acting in response. It is proactive method rather than reactive response to problem-solving. 1. Design a intervention strategy designed to target

Now that we’ve explored the question of what happens when police abuse your power, you’ll take act as chief of Atlanta Police one more time. In this

Now that we’ve explored the question of what happens when police abuse your power, you’ll take act as chief of Atlanta Police one more time. In this discussion, you’ll decide how your department would both strive to prevent and respond to issues of abuses of power. Steps to Complete Choose

Watch the Stanford Prison Experiment (2 Hours) Write a discussion post about how institutionalizing plays out in the experiment. What do you think about

Watch the Stanford Prison Experiment (2 Hours) Write a discussion post about how institutionalizing plays out in the experiment. What do you think about how the inmates and officers behaved? What do you know about how institutionalization that might explain these behaviors? Do you think these behaviors are justified because of institutionalization,

Choose a topic covered in this module you would like to know more about. Do a little research and find a reading, podcast, or video that sparks your

Choose a topic covered in this module you would like to know more about. Do a little research and find a reading, podcast, or video that sparks your interest. Read, listen, and/or watch. Share what you have learned and found interesting. In the post also note the topic you choose,

In Week 8, you must submit a formal research paper (10-15 pages), which will be worth 45% of your course grade. Your paper needs to analyze the jury

In Week 8, you must submit a formal research paper (10-15 pages), which will be worth 45% of your course grade. Your paper needs to analyze the jury selection process and its relationship to both: (a) Constitutional law, and (b) an allied field (e.g., education, history, law enforcement, public administration,